CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION
(Room No.315, BWing, August Kranti Bhawan, Bhikaji Cama Place, New Delhi 110 066)
File No.CIC/DS/A/2013/002484SA
(Ms. Usha Devi Vs. Food & Supply, GNCTD, Delhi)
Date of decision : 26-09-2014
Information Commissioner :
Prof. M. Sridhar Acharyulu
(Madabhushi Sridhar)
Sections 3, 19(3) of the RTI
Summary :
As per National Food Security Act 2013, Public Distribution System (control) Order, 2001
and the Public Distribution System Control Order, 2001 not only the applicant is entitled
to information about the stock and sale details of FPS shop but also about the people in
general. The public authority is also under obligation to ensure that the record of FPS
shop is maintained properly, as allotment of the food grains is done in accordance with
that only. The Commission finds it necessary to remind the PIO and Public Authority that
they have a duty provide information both under RTI Act and NFS Act besides having to
duty to enquire into the complaint/ redress grievance of the card holders. Nowhere, were
they permitted to force to give statements of ‘nocomplaint’. Noting that it is a serious
obstruction to access to information, CIC directs the PIO and Public Authority to give
up such antiRTI and anti Food Security practice immediately and ensure information
required.
FACTS
2. The appellant submitted that through the RTI application dated 28052013 she had
sought a copy of the daily sale and stock register of sugar for the period January 2012 till April
2013 for Ration shop no. 8349. As she did not receive the requisite information, she filed a
first appeal dated 26072013. FAA in his Order dated 4092013, directed the PIO to provide
the requisite information within 10 days. As the PIO did not comply with the order of the FAA,
the appellant stated that she had to approach the commission in Second Appeal dated 2510
2013.
3
The appellant further stated after the filling of Second Appeal, she received a reply
on 29112013 which stated that information had been sent on 10102013 and that it is
enclosed again. The enclosure was a letter dated 12062013 signed by Mr. Yad Ram, FSO
C45 stating that the photocopy of the relevant pages can be obtained from the office of the
Asst. Commissioner (South) “after depositing the requisite amount”.
4. The appellant also submitted that the PIO tried to mislead the commission in the hearing
by stating that the FPS(ration shop) had closed and therefore the department did not have the
records which she had requested for. The appellant stated that it is a false claim as under
different statutory provisions and order of the government; the department is required to, on a
monthly basis and maintain the record.
2
5.
The appellant in her written submission has highlighted the various statutory
provisions under which, the ration shop was required to maintain and furnish copies of the
daily sale and stock registers to the department:
Circular No. 6(1)/Misc/CFS(D)/2005/370 dated 27/03/2006 of the department of food
supplies and consumer affairs, calls upon the assistant commissioners to submit monthly certificates
to the effect that:
1.
(a) SFA’s are available in each Fair Price Shop in the First week of the month
(b)
(c) Proper registers are being maintained to record the arrival of SFAs and opening of sale.
The quantity of drafts submitted during the month does not exceed the total monthly
allocation of the circle/ Fair price shop
As per ‘Ready Reckoner’ of Control Orders issued by the Department of Food and supplies
on 24/4/2005, the “Nonproduction of stock register, sale register... to the beneficiaries of the PDS...”
is recognised as a default by the Ration shop owner ender various control orders.
2.
As per the Order dated 15062006 of the Commissioner, Food and Supplies & Consumer
affairs department, public audit of the records of Fair price shops are to be held in all the circle offices
on every Saturday except for second Saturday. The guidelines direct the photocopy of the stock
register and sale register, attested by the ration shop owner, to be obtained by the department for the
audit.
3.
Prior to commencement of distribution of the Specified Food Articles to the ration card
holders, the officers of the department are required to open sale at the fair price shop level, once the
specified food articles have benn delivered ot the FPS from the FCI, is laid down on order no.
PS/CFS/F&S/2005/128 dated 06.04.2005 issued by the office of the commissioner, food supplies and
consumer affairs. The fair price shop owner is required to report the arrival of the food articles to the
food supply officer within three hours of the receipt of the stock indicating the quatity received and the
time of receipt. The circle FSO is then required to diarise the sadi information in a register. Tjhre area
inspector is then required to inspect to inspect the FPS within 3 hours of receipt of information and
therafter to record his visit in the receipt column of the stock register Vide Circular No.
F.6(1)/CFS(D)/Misc/2005/1430 dated 16.11.2005 the offce of the Commissioner of Food Supplies and
consumer affairs has directed all food supply officers to maintain details relating to opening of sale in
the fair price shops.
4.
5.
PDS Control Order 2001.
6. The appellant submitted that in the RTI application, she had sought copies of the daily sale
and stock registers of sugar for the period January 2012 till April 2013.The position taken by
the PIO at the hearing that the department is not required to obtain copies of daily sale and
stock registers of the ration shops, is untenable as per the abovementioned statutory
3
provisions. That the PIO is trying to mislead the commission by giving false and incorrect
information that the department is not required obtain/maintain records of the ration shop.
7. The appellant further submitted that it is unconceivable that the ration shop would have
been allowed to shut down without submitting records to the department. In any case, as per
the above mentioned statutory provisions and orders of the government, the sale and stock
records of ration shops have to be regularly inspected and obtained by the department on a
monthly basis from the ration shop. Therefore, even if the ration shop shut down, the requisite
records would have in any case been obtained on a monthly basis by the department, in
order to sanction supply for the next month.
8. The appellant therefore prayed before the Commission that direction be issued to PIO to
provide the information as requested in her RTI application and also penalize the PIO an
amount of Rs. 25000 for not furnishing the information within the stipulated timeframe.
DECISION:
9.
The Central Information Commission had observed in Mr. Rajiv Kumar Vs. The
Food Commissioner Department of Food & Supplies [CIC/SG/C/2009/001619; 001621;
001622/6047] with regard to SuoMotu availability of information in Circle Offices and the Fair
Price Shops as follows :
“The Commission discussed the various issues that were indicated in the Agenda which
included information that must be displayed at the Fair Price Shops and the Circle Offices
in compliance with the Department’s own orders as well as requirements of Section 4 of
the Right to Information Act 2005. After consultation with the Food Commissioner as well
as others present, the Commission directs that the following information should be
displayed at every Circle Office of the Department:
4
i) Copy of all ration cards along with photographs of individual card holders in the circle
offices of Food and Supply Department.
ii) All citizens should have access to daily sale register, and stock register under suo moto
disclosure of RTI Act.
iii) Name and designation of each official in the Circle office along with their stated roles
and responsibilities.
iv) Name and contact details of PIO’s and FAA.
v) Procedure to apply for new ration cards and the list of documents required.
vi) Time frame for disposal of various applications (new cards, renewal, change of
address etc).
vii) Date of the next Vigilance Committee meeting and names of the members of the
Committee.
viii) Rights and privileges of ration card holders as per Section 6(7) of Annexe to PDS
Control Order 2001.
ix) List of documents present in the Circle Offices.
The Complainant brought a sample display print of the information that may be displayed
outside each Fair Price Shop. Keeping this is view, the Commission directs that the
following information will be displayed at the Fair Price Shops under the Department:
i) Entitlement of essential commodities for all types of ration cards.
ii) Scale of issue of each essential commodity for all types of ration cards.
iii) Retail prices of each essential commodity for all types of ration cards.
iv) Working hours of fair price shops.
v) Stock of essential items received during the month.
vi) Opening and closing stock of essential commodities.
vii) Name, designation and contact numbers of officials for redressal of grievances with
respect to quality and quantity of essential commodities.
viii) Daily updation of stock position information
ix) Information about inspection of records by any citizen on every Saturday except for
second Saturday as per the PDS Control Order dated 15/06/2006.
x) Display of samples of food grains being supplied through fair price shops.
The Food Commissioner has given a commitment to the Commission that she will ensure
that the aforementioned information will be displayed before 31 January 2010.”
5
The enforcement of the above commitment by the Food Commissioner itself would have
solved the problem of the appellant and in many more similar cases.
10.
Heard both the parties. The appellant, a ration card holder sought to know the
copies of daily stock register and sale register pertaining to sugar from 1.1.2012 to 31.4.2013,
number of APL and BPL card at Kusumpur Phadi Vasanth Vihar, New Delhi area ration shop,
and where to complain if sugar is not given to her. She submitted that she has got the ration
sugar only once or twice in 6 months and during Diwali season. Her ration card entries are
falsely made by the FPS dealer, even though she did not receive the rations. A letter with her
signature has also been taken by a representative of the Respondent authority, saying that
she does not have any complaint regarding rations.
11.Mr S N Gaur, FSO of the respondent authority submitted that the relevant FPS dealer
resigned with effect from 2252013 and the appellant’s RTI application is dated 2852013
and hence they are having difficulty in supplying the information to the appellant as the
relevant sale and stock registers were not collected from the dealer. FSO also submitted that
they maintained the record only monthwise. FSO submitted that he is always cooperative
with the aggrieved ration card holders and redresses their grievances and offered his mobile
No.9810589215 or calling him.
12. With regard to the inspection of the stock and sale register, the commission has come
across a number of instances where the Public authority has either stated that the record is
not available or that the record from which FPS is sought is closed or not available. The
commission wants to bring into light the relevant provisions of the National Food Security
Act, 2013 which not only casts liability on the public authority to make the information
6
available, but also provides the relevant tools to the Public with regard to the inspection of the
record:
“CHAPTER IV – Identification of eligible households
....
Section 11 – Publication and display of list of eligible households :
The State Government shall place the list of the identified eligible households in the
public domain and display it prominently.
CHAPTER V – Reform in Targeted Public Distribution System
Section 12: Reforms in Targeted Public Distribution System
(1) The Central and State Governments shall endeavour to progressively
undertake necessary reforms in the Targeted Public Distribution System in
consonance with the role envisaged for them in this Act.
(2) The reforms shall, inter alia, include
(a) doorstep delivery of foodgrains to the Targeted Public Distribution
System outlets;
(b) application of information and communication technology tools
including endtoend computerisation in order to ensure transparent
recording of transactions at all levels, and to prevent diversion;
(c) leveraging "aadhaar" for unique identification, with biometric information
of entitled beneficiaries for proper targeting of benefits under this Act;
(d) full transparency of records;
(e) preference to public institutions or public bodies such as
Panchayats, selfhelp groups, cooperatives, in licensing of fair price
shops and management of fair price shops by women or their
collectives;
(f) diversification of commodities distributed under the Public Distribution
System over a period of time;
(g) support to local public distribution models and grains banks;
(h) introducing schemes, such as, cash transfer, food coupons, or other
schemes, to the targeted beneficiaries in order to ensure their foodgrain
entitlements specified in Chapter II, in such area and manner as may be
prescribed by the Central Government.
.
CHAPTER VII– Grievance Redressal Mechanism
7
Section 14: Internal grievance redressal mechanism :
Every State Government shall put in place an internal grievance redressal
mechanism which may include call centres, help lines, designation of nodal
officers, or such other mechanism as may be prescribed.
Section 15: District Grievance Redressal Officer
(1) The State Government shall appoint or designate, for each district, an officer to
be the District Grievance Redressal Officer for expeditious and effective redressal
of grievances of the aggrieved persons in matters relating to distribution of entitled
foodgrains or meals under Chapter II, and to enforce the entitlements under this
Act.
(2) The qualifications for appointment as District Grievance Redressal Officer and
its powers shall be such as may be prescribed by the State Government.
(3) The method and terms and conditions of appointment of the District Grievance
Redressal Officer shall be such as may be prescribed by the State Government.
(4) The State Government shall provide for the salary and allowances of the
District Grievance Redressal Officer and other staff and such other expenditure as
may be considered necessary for their proper functioning.
(5) The officer referred to in subsection (1) shall hear complaints regarding non
distribution of entitled foodgrains or meals, and matters relating thereto, and take
necessary action for their redressal in such manner and within such time as may
be prescribed by the State Government.
(6) Any complainant or the officer or authority against whom any order has been
passed by officer referred to in subsection (1), who is not satisfied with the
redressal of grievance may file an appeal against such order before the State
Commission.
(7) Every appeal under subsection (6) shall be filed in such manner and within
such time as may be prescribed by the State Government.
Section 16: State Food Commission
(1) Every State Government shall, by notification, constitute a State Food
Commission for the purpose of monitoring and review of implementation of this
Act.
(2) The State Commission shall consist of
(a) a Chairperson;
(b) five other Members; and
(c) a MemberSecretary, who shall be an officer of the State Government
not below the rank of Joint Secretary to that Government:
8
... ...
Provided that there shall be at least two women, whether
Chairperson, Member or MemberSecretary:
Provided further that there shall be one person belonging to the
Scheduled Castes and one person belonging to the Scheduled
Tribes, whether Chairperson, Member or MemberSecretary.
CHAPTER XI– Transparency and accountability
Section 27 – Disclosure of records of Targeted Public Distribution System.
All Targeted Public Distribution System related records shall be placed in the
Public domain and kept open for inspection to the public, in such manner as may be
prescribed by the State Government.
Section 28 Conduct of Social Audit
(1) Every local authority, or any other authority or body, as may be authorized by the
State Government, shall conduct or cause to be conducted, periodic social audits on the
functioning of fair price shops, Targeted Public Distribution System and other welfare
schemes ,and cause to publicize its findings and take necessary action, in such manner
as may be prescribed by the State Government.
(2) The Central Government may, if it considers necessary, conduct or cause to be
conducted
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (CONTROL) ORDER, 2001
GSR No.630 (E)Whereas the Central Government is of the opinion that it is necessary
and expedient so to do for maintaining supplies and securing availability and distribution
of essential commodities under the Public Distribution System;
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by section 3 of the Essential
Commodities Act, 1955 (10 of 1955), the Central Government hereby makes the following
order, namely:
.....
7. Licensing:
(1) The procedure for issue of licenses or authorization to the fair price shops for the
distribution of essential commodities under Public Distribution System and duties and
responsibilities of the fair price shop owners shall be as per paragraph 5 of the Annexe to
this Order.
(2) The ration card holder shall not be denied the supply as per entitlement of the
essential commodities, lying in stock, by the fair price shop owner under the Public
Distribution System;
9
(3) The fair price shop owner shall not retain ration cards after the supply of the essential
commodities.
(4) Any ration card holder desirous of obtaining extracts from the records of a fair price
shop owner may make a written request to such owner along with deposit of the fee
specified by the State Government.
(4A) Within fourteen days from the date of receipt of a request and the specified fee
under subclause (4), the fair price shop owner shall provide such extracts of records to
the ration card holder.
8. Monitoring:
The procedure for monitoring of the Public Distribution System including the functioning
of the fair price shops by the State Governments shall be as per paragraph 6 of the
Annexe to this Order.
10. Power of search and seizure :
(1) An authority authorised by State Government, shall be competent to inspect or
summon such records or documents as may be considered by him necessary for
examination and take extracts or copies of any records or documents produced before
him.
(2) If the said authority has reasons to believe on receipt of a complaint or otherwise that
there has been any contravention of the provisions of this Order or with a view to securing
compliance with this Order, he may enter, inspect or search the fair price shop or any
premises relevant to transactions of business of the fair price shop.
(3) The said authority may also search, seize or remove such books of accounts or stocks
of essential commodities where such authority has reason to believe that these have
been used or will be used in contravention of the provisions of this order.
(3A) The authority conducting search and seizure under subclause (3) shall inform the
State Government or an officer authorised by it in this behalf, the details of the search
conducted and the stocks of essential commodities so seized by them under that clause.
(4) The provisions of section 100 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973, relating to
search and seizure shall so far as may be, apply to search and seizure under this Order.
14. Provisions of the Order to prevail over previous Orders of State Governments:
The provisions of this Order shall have effect notwithstanding anything to the contrary
contained in any Order made by a State Government or by an officer of such State
Government before the commencement of this Order except as respects anything done,
or omitted to be done thereunder before such commencement
Annexe to the Public Distribution System Control Order, 2001
4. Distribution:
10
(1) The Food Corporation of India (FCI) or any other agency designated for the purpose
by the Central Government shall ensure physical delivery of foodgrains of fair average
quality to State Governments for distribution under the Public Distribution System, as per
the allocations made by the Central Government, within two weeks of the receipt of
payment from the State Governments and issue of release orders.
(2) State Governments shall, on getting allocation of foodgrains from the Central
Government, issue districtwise allocation orders authorising their agencies or nominees
to draw foodgrains from the FCI within ten days of the receipt of allocation orders made
by the Government of India
(3) The designated authority of the State Government shall ensure delivery of one copy of
allocation order made to the fair price shop simultaneously to Gram Panchayats or Nagar
Palikas or Vigilance Committees or any other body nominated for monitoring the
functioning of the fair price shops by the concerned State Government and such order
shall specify:
(i) Number of cards and units;
(ii) Balance in hand; and
(iii) Allocation made for each month in respect of a fair price shop.
(4) Gram Panchayats or Nagar Palikas or Vigilance Committees or any other body
nominated for monitoring the functioning of the fair price shop by State Governments
shall display the stocks of essential commodities allotted during the month to the fair price
shops on a notice board outside their office.
(5)While making monthly allocations to the fair price shops the designated authority of
State Governments shall take into account the balance stock, if any, lying undistributed
with the fair price shop owners for the subsequent allocations.
(6) State Governments shall make arrangements for taking delivery of essential
commodities issued by the Central Government by their designated agencies or
nominees from the FCI depots/godowns and ensure further delivery to the fair price shop
within the first week of the month for which allocation is made.
(7) Before making the payment to the FCI the representatives of State Governments or
their nominees and the FCI shall conduct joint inspection of the stocks of foodgrains
intended for issue to ensure that the stocks conform to the prescribed quality
specifications.
(8)The FCI shall issue to the State Governments stackwise sealed samples of the stocks
of foodgrains supplied to them for distribution under the Public Distribution System at the
time of despatch.
11
(9) State Governments shall exercise necessary checks to ensure that full quantity lifted
by them reaches their godowns and in turn the fair price shops.
(10) State Governments shall ensure that stocks of essential commodities under the
Public Distribution System, as issued from the FCI godowns, are not replaced by stocks
of inferior quality during storage, transit or any other stage till delivery to the ration card
holder.
5. Licencing:
State Governments shall issue an order under section 3 of the Act for regulating the sale
and distribution of the essential commodities. The licenses to the fair price shop owners
shall be issued under the said order by the `designated authority’ appointed by the State
Government and the authority shall lay down the duties and responsibilities of the fair
price shop owner. The responsibilities and duties of fair price shop owners shall include,
inter alia:
(i) sale of essential commodities as per the entitlement of ration card holders at the retail
issue prices fixed by the concerned State Government under the Public Distribution
System;
(ii) display of information on a notice at a prominent place in the shop on daily basis
regarding (a) list of BPL and Antodaya beneficiaries, (b) entitlement of essential
commodities, (c) scale of issue, (d) retail issue prices, (e) timings of opening and closing
of the fair price shop, (f) stock of essential commodities received during the month, (g)
opening and closing stock of essential commodities and (h) the authority for redressal of
grievances/lodging complaints with respect to quality and quantity of essential
commodities under the Public Distribution System;
(iii) maintenance of records of ration card holders (APL, BPL and Antyodaya), stock
register, issue or sale register;
(iv) furnishing of copies of specified documents, namely, ration card register, stock
register, sale register to the office of the Gram Panchayat or Nagar Palika or Vigilance
Committee or any other body authorized by State Governments for the purpose;
(v) display of samples of foodgrains being supplied through the fair price shop;
(vi) production of books and records relating to the allotment and distribution of essential
commodities to the inspecting agency and furnishing of such information as may be
called for by the designated authority;
12
(vii) accountal of the actual distribution of essential commodities and the balance stock at
the end of the month to the designated authority of the concerned State Government with
a copy to the Gram Panchayat;
(viii) opening and closing of the fair price shop as per the prescribed timings displayed on
the notice board.
6. Monitoring:
(1) State Governments shall ensure a proper system of monitoring of fair price shops and
prescribe model sale register, stock register and ration card register.
(2) State Governments shall ensure regular inspections of fair price shops not less than
once in six months by the designated authority. State Governments may issue orders
specifying the inspection schedule, list of check points and the authority responsible for
ensuring compliance with the said orders.
(3) Meetings of the Vigilance Committees on the Public Distribution System at the State,
District, Block and FPS level shall be held on a regular basis. The date and periodicity
shall be notified by State Governments However, the periodicity shall not be less than one
meeting a quarter at all levels.
(4) State Governments shall ensure a periodic system of reporting and the complete
information in this regard shall be sent in the prescribed form as follows:
(i) By fair price shops to the District Authorities by the 7th of the month following the
month for which allocation is made in Form ‘A’.
(ii) By the District Authorities to State Government by the 15th of the month following the
month for which allocation is made in Form ‘B’.
(iii) By the State Government to the Central Government by the end of the month
following the month for which allocation is made in Form ‘C’.
(5) Future allocation of foodgrains to States shall be linked to the receipt of regular
reports from the respective States and furnishing of utilization certificates by them within
a period of two months from the month for which allocation is made.
(6) State Governments shall ensure monitoring of the functioning of the Public
Distribution System at the fair price shop level through the computer network of the NIC
installed in the District NIC centers. For this purpose computerized codes shall be issued
to each FPS in the district.
(7) State Governments shall educate the ration card holders regarding their rights and
privileges under the Public Distribution System by use of electronic and print media as
well as display boards outside fair price shops.
13
(8) State Governments shall issue and adopt the Citizen’s Charter based on the model
Citizens Charter issued by the Central Government.
(9) The designated authority shall direct the concerned fair price shop owner to provide
relevant extracts of the documents maintained by him on an application made by a
beneficiary, on payment of a prescribed fee.”
As per National Food Security Act 2013, Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2001 and
the Public Distribution System Control Order, 2001 in the above referred provisions not only
the applicant is entitled to information about the stock and sale details of FPS shop but also
the people in general. The public authority is also under obligation to ensure that the record of
FPS shop is maintained properly, as allotment of the food grains is done in accordance to it
only.
13.
The PIO in this case was arguing on one hand that information sought was not
available and on the other, saying that after she filed application, the Fair Price Shop Dealer
resigned and thus they could not give any information. During the hearing it was also revealed
that the appellant was made to sign a letter saying that she did not have any complaint
against the Fair price shop dealer. The PIO himself has submitted the signed copy of
appellant stating she had no complaint at all. The NGO representatives who assisted the
appellant in filing and pursuing RTI application alleged that the appellants were forced by the
officers to sign ‘nocomplaint’ letters to counter their RTI applications.
14.
The Commission finds the action and responses of the PIO in this case are self
contradictory and totally against the letter and spirit of both legislations, the Right to
Information Act, 2005 and the National Food Security Act, 2013. Generally, the BPL card
holders do not even dare to give a complaint against the dealers, though they do not receive
ration regularly. They quietly suffer the breach of ration supply norms. But it is quite
14
uncommon and almost impossible that such illiterate woman like appellant to write a letter
especially to the FSO that she had no complaint at all. The PIO told the Commission that they
also need to build a file to counter the campaign of NGOs through BPL card holders who are
directed to file multiple RTI application against the Fair Price Shop Dealers. He has alleged
that NGOs are forcing the BPL card holders to file RTI applications. He has produced a
Photostat copy of appellant’s ration card which showed her signatures for receipt of ration.
She explained that it was for food grains and not for sugar.
15.
The Commission finds it necessary to remind the PIO and Public Authority that
they have a duty to provide information both under RTI Act and NFS Act besides having to
duty to enquire into the complaint/ redress grievance of the card holders. Nowhere, were they
permitted to procure forced letters of ‘nocomplaint’. The Commission views it as a serious
obstruction to access to information, directs the PIO and Public Authority to give up such
antiRTI and anti Food Security practice immediately as that such forced procurement of no
complaint letters would be a practice against the objective of RTI Act attracting provisions of
Section 20 of RTI Act, for imposing penalty.
16.
The Commission directs the public authority to provide information relating to the
Fair Price Shop referred in the RTI application, either monthwise/datewise, to the appellant
within 15 days from the date of receipt of this order free of cost.
17. The Commission also recommends the public authority to treat the appellant’s RTI
application as a complaint and inquire into the matter and they should also create a
mechanism to provide daily stock and sale register as stipulated by the NFS Act, so that
manipulations by the FPS dealers can be prevented. They are also recommended to enforce
a uniform policy of providing information to the people in general regarding distribution of
15
rations as per the Sections 12 and 27 of the National Food Security Act, 2013. The
Commissioner for Food, Supply and Consumer Affairs is legitimately expected to create a
mechanism for easy access to this kind of information as per the requirements under NFS
Act, which is also mandated by Section 4(1)(b) of the RTI Act.
18. With the above observations, the Commission disposes of the appeal.
(M. Sridhar Acharyulu)
Information Commissioner
Authenticated true copy
(Babu Lal)
Deputy Registrar
Address of the parties:
1. The CPIO under RTI, Govt. Of NCT of Delhi,
Department of Food and Supply, Asstt. Commissioner
South District, Asian Market, Sector3,
Pushp Vihar, NEW DELHI
2. Smt. Usha Devi,
C42, Kusum Pur Pahari, Vasant Vihar
New Delhi110070
3. The Commissioner for Food, Supplies and Consumer Affairs
Department of Food & Supply, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
16
Secretariat, I.P. Estate, New Delhi110002
17
No comments:
Post a Comment